Arman Tsarukyan has thrown fuel on the fire of MMA’s greatest lightweight debate, boldly naming Islam Makhachev over his mentor’s legend, Khabib Nurmagomedov. The comment, made during an appearance on Adin Ross’ Kick stream, has rippled through the UFC world, challenging long-held views about who truly stands atop the 155-pound mountain.
During the live stream, Tsarukyan was asked to choose between Islam Makhachev, the reigning welterweight champ and double-title holder, and Khabib Nurmagomedov, the unbeaten lightweight icon turned coach. Without hesitation, Tsarukyan replied, “Islam’s more well-rounded, and he’s got Khabib in his corner.”
That comment comes not long after Makhachev dismantled Jack Della Maddalena at UFC 322 to become the promotion’s eleventh double champion. While Khabib never chased a second belt—retiring undefeated at UFC 254 in 2020—Makhachev has conquered lightweight and welterweight gold, cementing his status among the sport’s elite.
Tsarukyan’s viewpoint isn’t just hot takes; it’s born from personal history. He stepped into the octagon against Makhachev at UFC Saint Petersburg for his promotional debut, putting on a gritty performance but ultimately succumbing to the Dagestani’s grappling mastery. A planned rematch at UFC 311 was scrapped at the eleventh hour when Tsarukyan withdrew due to a back injury.
Meanwhile, Khabib’s legacy remains untarnished. He retired with a perfect 29-0 record, defeating the likes of Conor McGregor and Justin Gaethje. Since hanging up his gloves, he’s focused on coaching Islam, who’s built a stellar 26-1 mark under his guidance.
Tsarukyan’s pick spotlights a shift in how fans and fighters measure greatness. Is an undefeated run in one weight class more impressive than conquering two divisions? For Arman, the answer is clear: Makhachev’s résumé and skill set edge out even his own mentor.
This stance also underlines Islam’s evolution. Gone are the days when he was simply “Khabib’s protégé.” He’s developed an arsenal of striking, wrestling and jiu-jitsu, making him arguably the most complete lightweight in UFC history.
The remark could add tension to the lightweight rankings, too. Tsarukyan remains a top contender, likely eyeing a return to 155 pounds for another title shot. If he reels off a couple of wins, a trilogy bout with Makhachev could be on the cards—though Makhachev’s welterweight reign might keep them apart.
And what about Khabib? The undefeated former champ is busy moulding the next generation, but Tsarukyan’s endorsement of Makhachev as the superior fighter underscores that Khabib’s influence has paid dividends. His protégé’s rise is now central to the ongoing GOAT conversation.
By siding with Makhachev over Khabib, Arman Tsarukyan has stoked debate across the MMA community. His view challenges us to rethink what defines greatness: an unblemished record or the willingness to chase new heights. As Makhachev continues to solidify his legacy at two weight classes, Tsarukyan prepares his own path back to lightweight contention. One thing’s for sure—this conversation is far from over.
FAQ
Who did Arman Tsarukyan pick as the better fighter?
Tsarukyan chose Islam Makhachev over Khabib Nurmagomedov, citing Makhachev’s well-rounded skill set and having Khabib as his coach.
Why does Tsarukyan believe Makhachev is superior to Khabib?
He pointed to Makhachev’s ability to excel across striking, wrestling and jiu-jitsu, plus the advantage of having Khabib in his corner for guidance.
Has Islam Makhachev achieved more than Khabib in the UFC?
Yes. Makhachev has held titles in two weight classes—lightweight and welterweight—while Khabib retired undefeated as the lightweight champion.
Will Tsarukyan get a rematch with Makhachev?
It’s uncertain. Their scheduled title bout at UFC 311 fell through due to Tsarukyan’s back injury, and Makhachev is now focused on welterweight.
How does this debate affect the lightweight GOAT discussion?
Tsarukyan’s comments add a fresh perspective, challenging fans to weigh Khabib’s perfect record against Makhachev’s multi-division success when considering the greatest lightweight ever.
